Krugman on Truckers

Paul Krugman's post-mortem on the supposed truckers' convoy.  Casting bones and reading entrails he discerns the ugly face of today's right wing



The “Freedom Convoy” has been marketed as a backlash by truckers angry about Covid-19 vaccination mandates. In reality, there don’t seem to have been many truckers among the protesters at the bridge (about 90 percent of Canadian truckers are vaccinated). Last week a Bloomberg reporter saw only three semis among the vehicles blocking the Ambassador Bridge, which were mainly pickup trucks and private cars; photos taken Saturday also show very few commercial trucks.

So this isn’t a grass-roots trucker uprising. It’s more like a slow-motion Jan. 6, a disruption caused by a relatively small number of activists, many of them right-wing extremists. At their peak, the demonstrations in Ottawa reportedly involved only around 8,000 people, while numbers at other locations have been much smaller.

Any attempt to put a number on the economic costs of the blockade is tricky and speculative. However, it’s not hard to come up with numbers like $300 million or more per day; combine that with the disruption of Ottawa, and the “trucker” protests may already have inflicted a couple of billion dollars in economic damage.



That’s an interesting number, because it’s roughly comparable to insurance industry estimates of total losses associated with the Black Lives Matter protests that followed the killing of George Floyd — protests that seem to have involved more than 15 million people.

This comparison will no doubt surprise those who get their news from right-wing media, which portrayed B.L.M. as an orgy of arson and looting. I still receive mail from people who believe that much of New York City was reduced to smoking rubble. In fact, the demonstrations were remarkably nonviolent; vandalism happened in a few cases, but it was relatively rare, and the damage was small considering the huge size of the protests.

The B.L.M. demonstrations were a reaction to police killings of innocent people; what’s going on in Canada is, on its face, about rejecting public health measures intended to save lives. Of course, even that is mainly an excuse: What it’s really about is an attempt to exploit pandemic weariness to boost the usual culture-war agenda.

As you might expect, the U.S. right is loving it. People who portrayed peaceful protests against police killings as an existential threat are delighted by the spectacle of right-wing activists breaking the law and destroying wealth. Fox News has devoted many hours to fawning coverage of the blockades and occupations. Senator Rand Paul, who called B.L.M. activists a “crazed mob,” called for Canada-style protests to “clog up cities” in the United States, specifically saying that he hoped to see truckers disrupt the Super Bowl (they didn’t).

Recent events have confirmed what many suspected: The right is perfectly fine, indeed enthusiastic, about illegal actions and disorder as long as they serve right-wing ends.

Comments

  1. I don't think we can discount the influence of foreign interference be it USA or Russia.
    Then there are the shit stirrers , born to disrupt anything in their path, we all know one.
    A man of God (LOL) was arrested at the Coutts crossing and as we area all aware so were the Alberta GI Joes with their arms cache.
    It;s the Trump syndrome , the loonies ( not a nice phrase) are trying to rule the patch!
    Sadly those in our taxpayer employ , the politicians law enforcement officials etc are not up to the task of doing the job they are paid for.
    It is the fault of the voter who, on election day, votes for the low hanging fruit as in lower gas prices not clean water etc ..

    In short; we enabled the current situation.

    TB


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Some of us enabled this, TB. I don't want to read too much into this. There seems to be a generational trait whereby seniors see chaos and mayhem in younger generations, the wild bunch. However Canadians also have a lazy reliance on others to do "the right thing." These mobs threaten the tranquil society to which all of us want to belong. Today's parties govern for their own benefit, not the public interest especially where the two conflict. This comes through not merely on this truckers' farce but on the climate emergency, inequality, and indifference to representative democracy.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Gun We Point at Our Own Heads

Navigating the Minefield of Short-Termism

The Cognoscenti Syndrome