The Rot of Democracies - Elliot Cohen
Liberal democracy, as widely observed, is in retreat around the world. How much more can it take before it's in rout?
Tribalism is sweeping America. We have in our own "progressive" ranks some who obsessively demonize the other side. Conservatives, they routinely argue, must be destroyed.
In his recent column in The Atlantic, Eliot Cohen, warns that American tribalism could bring the world order crashing to the ground.
Cohen worries that: The latest poll results from the University of Virginia Center for Politics, in which about three-quarters of Joe Biden and Donald Trump voters say that representatives of the opposing party are “a clear and present danger to American democracy,” and that censorship should be introduced, the First Amendment to the Constitution notwithstanding.In that time, whose living memory has vanished with the passing of the older generation, cancel culture was real; George Orwell, among others, felt it. On one side, intellectuals infatuated with communism, or who were simply following the dictum that there are no enemies on one’s left, felt comfortable preventing critics from being able to publish or even getting jobs. On the other side, a minority, now somewhat forgotten but important at the time, became infatuated with toxic forms of nationalism, and not only among the future Axis powers.
...In short, liberal democracy feels as though it’s in a pretty bad way, and in many places, it is. No competing advanced ideologies as comprehensive and lethal as Nazism or communism are on offer, although that could conceivably change. What is certain is that dictators, whether Xi Jinping or Ayatollah Khamenei, Vladimir Putin or Kim Jong Un, have at their disposal devastating weapons of precision repression and murder. The repeated and generally successful crushing of dissident individuals and movements in their countries and elsewhere is remarkable.
...We have yet to experience the full external shocks of climate change, and we have yet, for that matter, to see what will happen when someone again lights off a nuclear weapon in anger. It was not without reason that Churchill spoke of the possibility of the world sinking “into the abyss of a new Dark Age made more sinister, and perhaps more protracted, by the lights of perverted science.” It all could happen, and if the first half of the 20th century has anything to teach us, it is that calamitous misfortune and horrifying deeds can occur, a lesson viscerally absorbed by the statesmen who attempted to piece the world back together in the first decade after World War II.
Churchill could pin his hopes on the world’s biggest economy and its liveliest (if turbulent) democracy, the United States. The problem today is that there is no United States behind the United States. If America succumbs to its internal divisions, to its preoccupation with partisan feuding and its desire to withdraw from international politics, the world order, such as it is, will crumble.
In my experience, Canadians today, even those who see themselves as politically engaged, view our democracy as somehow healthy, secure and immune. Yet how often do we rebuke those who fan the flames of tribalism and see those in other camps, with different views, as somehow second-rate and to be dominated by those of purer thought? How does that end?
Politics in Western Nations has become a "zero sum game" my friend. When was the last time a senior member of government in Canada (or one of its provinces) resigned for a flagrant act of corruption or incompetence? Respectful dialogue between politicians of differing views is now considered a quaint anachronism. However, the voting public is not without blame. Unless we demand change, and hold elected officials and public servants to account, things will continue to deteriorate.
ReplyDeleteAs long as we paint our political opponents in catastrophic colours, our democracy will be at risk, Mound.
ReplyDeleteSome of us insist on playing these destructive games, Owen. When the other team receives more votes than your team to dismiss them out of hand is awfully arrogant.
DeleteCanadians today, even those who see themselves as politically engaged, view our democracy as somehow healthy, secure and immune.
ReplyDeleteEdward Snowden said that the real damaging conspiracies' are not the ones we identify
it is the ones we take for granted and are false illusions that bind and destroy us .
I believe the illusion of our democracy being "of the people, for the people , by the people"
is one of them
We are managed and given the illusion of choice and self management
remember "if voting mattered they wouldn't let us do it ?"
it's just an ego appeasing diversion
You'll get no argument from me, Lungta.
DeleteI'm still wondering just who 'they' are ?
ReplyDeleteTB