America on the Edge of Revolt? Grumblings from the Military Underworld.
The Big Lie, January 6, Proud Boys, Boogaloo Boyz, white supremacists, the Klan, white nativists, militia violence and a supremely radicalized Republican Party. Now America's military leadership may add momentum to the building upheaval.
A chilling open letter from retired US generals and admirals released this week denounces Democrats as Marxists and socialists that imperil America's constitutional democracy.
Aside from the (stolen) election, the Current Administration has launched a full-blown assault on our Constitutional rights in a dictatorial manner, bypassing the Congress, with more than 50 Executive Orders quickly signed, many reversing the previous Administration’s effective policies and regulations. Moreover, population control actions such as excessive lockdowns, school and business closures, and most alarming, censorship of written and verbal expression are all direct assaults on our fundamental Rights. We must support and hold accountable politicians who will act to counter Socialism, Marxism and Progressivism, support our Constitutional Republic, and insist on fiscally responsible governing while focusing on all Americans, especially the middle class, not special interest or extremist groups which are used to divide us into warring factions.This 'open letter,' tinged with Stanley Kubrik/Dr. Strangelove-grade menace, evidences a break in civil-military protocols intended to safeguard democracy. From Foreign Policy magazine:
Perhaps we should not be shocked to discover that, at a time when American society is reeling from extreme partisan polarization—when significant numbers of prominent politicians are openly promoting falsehoods such as the bogus claim that Trump’s resounding defeat at the ballot box was due to electoral fraud—some fraction of the retired military community has fallen prey to the same myths. If a problem exists in civilian society, one can expect to see it in the military assigned to protect that society as well.
What makes the letter so disturbing is that the 124 signatories are all retired members of a profession whose treasured principles demand that it be subject to civilian command and should remain separate from parochial partisan politics. This is a group of men—and it appears they are all men—who repeatedly pledged an oath of allegiance to the U.S. Constitution and are now doing their level best to undermine it and, in particular, the crucial principle of civilian control.
In the letter, the group calling itself “Flag Officers 4 America” writes: “We are in a fight for our survival as a Constitutional Republic like no other time since our founding in 1776. The conflict is between supporters of Socialism and Marxism vs. supporters of Constitutional freedom and liberty.”
...This letter is a primal scream by several scores of older Republican men who are angry that the electorate, in a free and fair election, chose Biden as president instead of their preferred candidate, Trump. Rather than accept this defeat and prepare for the next election, they are trying to delegitimize the victory by making false claims about the duly elected commander in chief.
They are entitled to believe untruths, even to express untruths, but the only reason we bother noticing them is that they once were commanders in the most potent coercive instrument of state power, the military—and the nagging fear that they might be speaking for others who have the potential to wield real coercive power now.

What I find 'chilling' is that these MF's have no idea what socialism is !
ReplyDeleteI grew up in the UK of Harold Wilson who was, like him or not, a true socialist.
America has never had anything close to socialism or communism.
FFS, it's never had a decent "social" safety net!
These medal clad relics of the cold war personify the worst of Amerika.
With the lack of immediate action at the attempted coup in Washington i can only guess just how many current officers share these same views.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=do_rHW8aJQ0
TB
Bacevich explores this in his book, The New American Militarism. Part of it looks at how the military hierarchy has come to embrace Christian fundamentalism in its drift to the far right. In my day the officer corps was C of E for the Brits, Anglican for Canada and Episcopalian for the Americans. It was old school Protestant. A radicalized military is a politicized military and we ignore that at our peril.
DeleteBeyond chilling.
ReplyDeleteI'd like to see OMPFs of the signatories. These guys seem to think they know a lot about dictators. The letter comes off as a knitting circle activity for retired faculty members of the School of the Americas that's gone off the rails. It was never intended that curriculum content that revealed the unarticulated mission of the project would go public. Even when probable, the future onset of cognitive decline is seldom given sufficient attention.
In their view, I guess America really has become another Banana Republic. If so, at least they got that part right.
Well they're going public with it now, John.
DeleteNew Zealand is very appealing.
ReplyDeleteThe army interfered in UK politics in 1974.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.historyextra.com/period/20th-century/lord-mountbatten-did-prince-philip-uncle-attempt-lead-coup-harold-wilson-government-crown-true/
The use of troops was not authorized by parliament..
https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/lords/1974/jan/16/heathrow-exercise-use-of-armed-forces
TB
It's not unusual for the military to pull an oar for a failing right wing government or to oppose a progressive opposition.
ReplyDeleteWhen we experience this in the West we are appalled , when it happens in centro America or Africa we turn our heads.
This is possible because of the years of indoctrination training that most militaries are faced with.
For god , queen , country , constitution or whatever are hardly a starting point for open discussion, inclusion or progress.
TB
As we saw repeatedly in South and Central America from the 60s onward, the US tended to treat the military establishment in these nations as its vassals to keep governments in line. The irony is, at the end of the day, most democratic reform emanated from the ranks of junior officers than the political establishment, the Latifundia or landed gentry. The military in those lands was usually the best or only vehicle of social mobility open to the peasant class. You might begin as a private soldier, advance to lieutenant or captain and then, together with other like-minded officers, stage a coup d'etat. That often preceded land reform, the key to transferring political power to the working classes. Some of this was even inspired by Kennedy's Alliance for Progress, albeit unintentionally.
Delete