We Wuz Robbed


The real losers in the federal election were the people of Canada.

The Tyee takes a look at how the election would have turned out if, instead of the rigged first-past-the-post system, we voted under either proportional representation or single transferrable vote systems.

A single transferrable vote system would have handed the Tories a razor thin edge over the Libs. It would have more than doubled New Democrat seats, handing the NDP a solid balance of power.

Mixed member proportional would have delivered a modest lead to the Liberals but a doubling of New Dem seats, again giving the NDP the balance of power.

 

Comments

  1. rumleyfipsOctober 2, 2021 at 6:53 AM

    The more commentary I read the less sense proposed systems make. Our present system allows small rural riding ( like the one I live in ) more influence than far larger urban riding . They both get one member but proportionality doesn't exist.
    That said the others are all flawed as well. PR is unconstitutional, just ask PEI. MP's would be divorced from local representation. Single transferable is complicated, silly and the prevailing party would still not be the voters intended choice. Second and third choices aren't what people really want . Mixed member Prop just as bad: no real winner and MP's with no riding responsibilities.

    A close look tells me that under any of these 4 systems, the result would be the same; a minority government led by a centrist party .

    ReplyDelete
  2. thwapOctober 2, 2021 at 7:11 AM

    I can't recall any MP in the past 37 years who was essential to me for anything personally. Nothing that couldn't be handled by a bureaucrat. This idea that getting an MP to better represent the broad brush strokes (right-wing/centrist/left-wing/socialist/environmentalist/what-have-you) through proportional representation will be a death-blow to democracy at the constituency level is ridiculous nonsense.

    ReplyDelete
  3. rumleyfipsOctober 2, 2021 at 9:35 AM

    I went back and reread the post. It remains unconvincing. PR is unconstitutional but the author led with it to say the liberals lost for clickbait. Mixed member attracts me a bit but we would have the same results no matter what systems. A minority government from an election where nobody won a majority but where . depending on the system, the numbers are massaged two or three times to arrived at a " majority ".

    Lets face it folks : Canadians did not vote for a majority no matter how their wishes could be manipulated under a different system.

    I have never spoken to my MP in 52 years of voting, but I want to see local representation.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Up in Smoke. 300 Sq. Mi. of Amazon Rainforest Lost Every Day.

Image
  The Amazon rainforest is disappearing at what should be an alarming rate. 312 sq. mi. or 808 sq. kms. every day. Over the past 30 years humans have destroyed a patch of the Amazon equal in area to the states of Texas and New Mexico . The Amazon – historically a great carbon absorber, since trees take in carbon dioxide and release oxygen – now releases more carbon than it stores, which adds to, rather helps to reduce, our global climate crisis. Deforestation rates decreased slightly from 2004 to 2012. But since then, they’re back on the rise, especially in the past couple of years, since Jair Bolsonaro became president of Brazil. In 2018, as Bolsonaro campaigned as a patriotic man of the people, scientists predicted that once the Amazon lost more than 25% of its tree cover, it would become a drier ecosystem, all because deforestation changes weather patterns (due to how trees respire), which in turn reduces rainfall. Furthermore, as the forest becomes fragmented, areas surrounded by
Read more

The Cognoscenti Syndrome

  There is a group of people I think of as the Cognoscenti, people who are well educated, very informed and of rapidly diminishing relevance. Their ranks include writers such as Chris Hedges and Glen Greenwald. These are people who have honed an almost Puritanical value system, readily finding fault in any direction. They are scathing in their attacks on Republicans and Democrats alike to the point where they become nihilists. They don't endorse. They prescribe. This is where they fail. They're unable to advocate for anything that might resonate with the public whose interests they argue are being trammeled. Donald Trump was bad but Joe Biden is scarcely better. This is where their elitism comes in.  74 million may have voted for Trump but, hey, they didn't know any better. The mob that stormed the Capitol. They were just victims of the system venting their frustrations. All the racism, bigotry, xenophobia, misogyny, white nationalism - inevitable side effects of their oppr
Read more

"Creeping Normalcy" in the Plague Age

Image
  Britain is experiencing a new wave of Covid cases, 40,000 per day .  Yet it hasn't caused much reaction from the public. It sounds like the legendary stiff upper lip, the "Keep Calm and Carry On" resolve. Health officials think it's something much more troubling. “We’re in a phase where we still have large numbers of people dying from this disease,” said Linda Bauld, professor of public health at the University of Edinburgh. “But it has gone into the background. We’ve become used to something that has not gone away. I think there’s been a desensitisation to the mortality.” On Thursday, the UK reported more than 45,000 new coronavirus cases – the most since mid-July – and more than 800 deaths were reported in the past seven days. Hospitalisations are rising, with one-fifth of ICU beds occupied by Covid patients, and the latest figures showed an estimated 200,000 pupils absent from school. The UK is faring far worse than its European neighbours, with a rate of death
Read more